Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez: ‘Electoral College is a scam, reservations should get a vote’

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-N.Y., responds to base remarks by President Donald Trump after his call for four Democratic congresswomen of color to go back to their "broken" countries, as he exploited the nation's glaring racial divisions once again for political gain, during a news conference at the Capitol in Washington, Monday, July 15, 2019. AP Photo/J. Scott Applewhite

The New York Congresswoman either ‘has a point’ or ‘should go back to civics class’

Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, D-New York, is known for her direct and unflinching calling out of her political views across the spectrum of politics. Last week she said the Electoral College is a “bogus, scam” and that Native American reservations should be given a vote.

Cortez called out the Electoral College in an Instagram story post that was picked up internationally by media organizations. The Electoral College awards presidential candidates votes by state instead of via the popular vote. There have been five presidential contenders who won the election even though they did not receive the majority of votes.

President Donald Trump is the most current example. He won the presidency against Hillary Clinton with 304 electoral votes to Clinton’s 227 votes. Yet she earned the most popular votes of 65,853,514 to Trump's 62,984,828 votes, approximately 2.87 million fewer than Clinton.

After her initial Instagram story post, Cortez then stated she would not back down. Now This News grabbed her response video and added transcriptions in which Cortez stated the following in part:

“I'm not taking it back. It's bogus. It's a scam. I talked about how bogus the Electoral College is and Fox News got really mad. It's not even about rural voters vs. urban voters … If you cared about the voices of rural voters you would allow all of the rural voters to come together and have their votes counted,” said Cortez. 

Cortez also explained that Republican voters in blue states have votes that are essentially erased, but in a popular vote, “everyone’s vote would count equally.”

“Why don't we give Indian reservations an electoral vote? Why don't we give Puerto Rico and US territories — hundreds of thousands of U.S. citizens, If not millions of U.S. citizens have zero representation,” she said.

Indian Country Today found that the American Indian and Alaska voters are underrepresented across the political system. 

“The mechanics of the Electoral College and the idea of counting every vote ought to be front and center in every election. The United States version of democracy is structured to make sure that we are not equal,” wrote Mark Trahant in What kind of democracy? One where Native votes are counted. 

“But it’s not just the Electoral College. It’s the Senate. It’s the districting system in the U.S. House of Representatives (and for that matter, in most state legislatures). The fact, yes, the fact is the structure of this democracy does not ensure a reflection of the country. So every vote does not count the same.”

CNN’s opinion writer Robert M. Alexander said in a recent op-ed, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez has a point about the Electoral College with the following statement:

‘Winning the electoral vote but losing the popular vote can complicate claims to legitimacy. Legitimacy is a key factor in any government. The belief that one has a right to their position is a deeply rooted feature for political stability. While it is established that the Electoral College is the process we use to determine who wins the presidency, how a president wins in the Electoral College matters in what they are able to accomplish.”

Then, as Trahant wrote, “President Donald J. Trump was a longtime critic of the Electoral College until he won because of that very structural imbalance.”

ICT Phone Logo

Follow Indian Country Today’s associate editor Vincent Schilling (Akwesasne Mohawk) on Twitter - @VinceSchilling and Instagram - @VinceSchilling

Email - vschilling@indiancountrytoday.com

Comments (30)
No. 1-5
Ms Peggy Lee
Ms Peggy Lee

Exactly! I'm with Alexandria!

7 Replies

Flybum
Flybum

Then you need some civics education. Some understanding of who you are and what government is would be helpful.

Ms Peggy Lee
Ms Peggy Lee

I'm a retired public school teacher - middle school math/Lang arts. I "got me some civics", too.

Flybum
Flybum

Oh sorry to hear that. Their lies the problem, indoctrinated thought. Did you teach to think or to believe like you were indoctrinated to believe? Why would a free and sovereign nation want anything to do with a political corporation? PLEASE EDUCATE US MS TEACHER.

Ms Peggy Lee
Ms Peggy Lee

Okay, first, "their lies the problem". Do you mean, their lies, or do you mean, there lies??? Also, define political corporation. THX

Flybum
Flybum

Your reply speaks volumes about your indoctrination. My mistake of not proofing before submitting is error. One must watch these electronic devices as they can change on you. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, STATE OF OHIO, or any of the other 49 STATES that are artificial entities. Legal definition of corporation. Do you reside in a geographical area or a artificial entity? The English language is complex and words can have different meaning even within the same spelling. I can respect your asking for clarification of my error. I do not respect indoctrinated thought being parroted. Great people not knowing who they are or where they reside should be respected by no-one, ever. Ignorance is a dead end road to serfdom.

Flybum
Flybum

That original reply could also mean you are the problem by teaching from ignorance rather than facts. Being honest I do not remember my thoughts at the moment. I certainly could of been implying that passing bad\ incomplete information is a problem. Either way I mean no personal animosity towards you. Just trying to get those with inquiring minds to open them. Hope this helps. Arguing and fighting does not. That is a problem with posting and not knowing a person. The President has that problem, in spades. (no, that was not racist.) lol

Ms Peggy Lee
Ms Peggy Lee

Your "rants" speak volumes of nonsense. I admire you for trying to communicate effectively, though. 👏

Harv Hilowitz
Harv Hilowitz

A.O.C. is a complete headline grabbing airhead. Was she a "socialist" when she was tending bar last year? Or when she and her boyfriend were partners in real estate speculations in New York City? Is she a member of the Socialist Party USA? Is she a Marxist- Leninist, a Bukharinite, a Trotskyite? She knows absolutely ZERO about the USA and its policies and history, and even less about Indian Country issues.

walks-alone
walks-alone

the Constitution set up the Electoral College ,to assure the entire country- nomatter how many states- was fairly represented in the election- then- New York City and Philadelphia- would have elected every president- - remove the system- NY, NJ, California, Florida ,NM, can win every election- Clinton won 12 states with 63 million votes- it would leave out the middle- and red - states-

satlite440
satlite440

a.o.c. is the dumbest ,most populist spouter of garbage I have ever heard.and when she speaks we are all the dumber for it...fuck mob rule and if you beleave in that stupid populare vote shit.remember the whiles who think we are dead could vote mob rule to take what little we do have away from us by that method of voating

JHp
JHp

I vote by facts and real humanitarian efforts. I DO NOT SEE THAT in the Democratic party, just more separation, confusion, hatred, and of our Country.