Cops who Killed George Floyd Repeat Myth: "If you can Speak, you can Breathe"

Carlos Miller

Minneapolis police were caught on video murdering a man under the state's legal definition but have yet to be charged.

For eight grueling minutes, Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin kept his knee firmly planted on George Floyd's neck as the 46-year-old man pleaded for his life until he could plead no more. And for eight grueling minutes, the four cops involved did nothing to save his life.

"He’s talking, he’s fine,” a cop tells a witness as Chauvin is killing Floyd, repeating a myth that cops love to spread after they kill people in chokeholds. If police truly believe this, then they should allow us to place them in chokeholds to prove their point but that would result in an attempted murder charge.

The myth has been repeated by police in the wake of several controversial incidents in which they killed people after placing them in a chokehold, including the case of Eric Garner and Kelly Thomas. And it will probably be repeated by the cops' defense attorney if this case ever goes to trial, knowing American juries are easily manipulated when it comes to police abuse.

The myth is apparently passed down to cops in the police academy when all cadets are forced to go through a moral readjustment that strips them of all compassion and common sense.

But according to a 2014 post on Reddit, a person claiming to have worked as a cop posted a lengthy and detailed explanation as to why somebody can easily be choked to death even if they are able to say they can't breathe.

The explanation gets very technical but it basically boils down to humans having a reserve air supply in their lungs that allows them to speak even if they are unable to draw oxygen into the lungs which is what is needed for survival. It's basically a final desperate plea for compassion that regularly goes ignored by those who are supposed to protect and serve (which is another myth that would be laughable if not so deadly). The blog post is published below in its entirety.

The myth is so prevalent that in 2014, a former Baltimore cop turned criminal justice professor named John Moskos published a lengthy blog post trying to justify the Eric Garner killing by repeating the myth that Garner was able to breathe since he was saying he could not breathe.

But then Moskos acknowledged his ignorance by admitting he had been wrong, posting a link to the Reddit user above.

The problem is, this myth is apparently still being taught to the cops because they not only continue to choke people over minor crimes, they continue to defend their actions by repeating the myth.

The quickest way to dispel the myth would be to charge all four Minneapolis cops for the murder of Floyd because the evidence shows their actions meet the standards for third-degree murder under Minnesota law which states the following:


(a) Whoever, without intent to effect the death of any person, causes the death of another by perpetrating an act eminently dangerous to others and evincing a depraved mind, without regard for human life, is guilty of murder in the third degree and may be sentenced to imprisonment for not more than 25 years.

But the fact they have not been charged can be attributed to their Blue Privilege which has become so normalized in our society, most people don't even question it.

However, if the anger over Floyd's death demonstrated on the streets of Minneapolis Tuesday night is any indicator, people are not going to let this go until all four of those cops have been arrested and convicted for murder. Nor should they.

Some of those protesters also gathered in front of Chauvin's home which prompted police to surround it with officers, an act that was not afforded to Floyd when he laid under Chauvin's neck pleading for his life. The protesters plan to return today.

Below is a video of George Floyd from when he was alive where he is preaching non-violence to young, black men. His friends and family all say Floyd was a peaceful, loving man.

Chauvin, on the other hand, has a reputation for violence and excessive force during his two-decade career as a cop, having received multiple complaints from citizens, none of them resulting in any discipline as you can see in the images below which were uncovered by Heavy. Chauvin has also been involved in three shootings but cleared of all wrongdoing in all of them.

UPDATE: The names of the four cops involved have been released; Derek Clauvin, Tau Thao, Thomas Lane and J. Alexander Kueng.

Below is also a live stream of a protest currently taking place in Minneapolis.

Here is the blog post dispelling the myth.

The Pernicious Myth Of "If You Can Speak You Can Breathe" by 17th_knight

"This is a phrase I heard Peter King say in the wake of Eric Garner's death and I feel it's something that everyone in our profession needs to be aware of. The myth of "If you can speak you can breathe".

I know I have heard it said twice by officers I work with, whom I both corrected. One of them actually argued with me about it until I was able to get Fire and Rescue to tell them they are wrong. The LAPD killed a man because they ignored his pleas and told him that if he could speak he could breathe. THIS IS FALSE!!!!!!!!! And clearly officers nationwide are not being properly trained to know that it is false. Knowing that this myth persists, and knowing I have heard actual officers repeat it in my presence, I felt it needed to be addressed.

Hearing that phrase come out of someone's mouth always upsets me, because it can easily lead to a preventable death.So let's explore why this is false, because anyone who comes up against a situation like this needs to realize that You CAN speak if you cannot breathe!!

This is true for multiple reasons, so let's explore them:

The lungs have what are called "Volumes" and "Capacities". The link describes all of them. For our purposes, you need to understand these two phrases: Functional Reserve Capacity (the amount of air left in the lungs after a normal exhalation) and Expiratory Reserve Volume (the amount of air you can still force out of your lungs after a normal exhalation).
When you take a normal breath you breathe in and out you are breathing about 500ml of air. After breathing out, you are left with ~2400ml of air inside your lungs, this is the Functional Reserve Capacity. If you try to force out as much air as possible, you can still force out ~1200ml more air. This is the Expiratory Reserve Volume. This is air you are able to speak with even if you cannot take a normal breath. Important Note: Notice that the Expiratory Reserve Volume is more than twice the size of a normal breath. That is a lot of air you are able to force out, and a lot of speaking you can do even if you can't breathe.
The lungs work on negative pressure. So, your lungs, when you breathe in, are at a lower pressure than the outside air. This draws the air into them. This is caused by your diaphragm and intercostal muscles. Your lungs are very elastic, and will move back to their normal size during exhalation. This is where the problem begins for officers. If you are kneeling on a suspect, or you have them handcuffed on the ground so that they are on their chest, there is a strong possibility that you can cut off their ability to breathe. Once the lungs begin to exhale, they collapse, but if you they are being pressed down on by body weight, they may not be able to re-expand. They then continue to collapse, forcing out the Functional Reserve Capacity of air, but not drawing in a new breath. So, your suspect may be pleading for breath, they may actually be incapable of drawing one in, and the reason is you. If someone is saying they cannot breathe, you need to believe them, because you might be killing them. Furthermore, during any kind of physical altercation, that person may be breathing deeply and rapidly, making their lungs collapse faster when you are kneeling on them or holding them on the ground.
Asthma. Some of you may be saying "Well, the guy who died in LAPD's care had asthma, that wasn't the officer's fault or the jail's fault." Oh yes it was. If someone is telling you they have asthma and they can't breathe, you need to believe them. Asthma is a constriction of the airways, no different than being strangled. They will still be able to speak and they will still be dying slowly. It took 30 minutes for that man to die, and that was entirely preventable.

First Demonstration: Take a normal breath in and then a normal breath out. Then, after exhaling, force out as much air as you possibly can. Even after doing this, you will find you are able to speak. I am able to speak for about 5 - 10 seconds afterwards, in short, wheezing, gaspy words, but I can speak. If you don't inhale at this point, you will begin to suffocate, but you will still be capable of speech even as you are dying. IMPORTANT EDIT: And that's not to say a person will only be able to speak for a few seconds, they could speak for minutes while being unable to draw a breath in. Keep in mind, you are purposely forcing out the Expiratory Reserve Volume during this demonstration, but a suspect/inmate might not be. They may be on the ground, unable to breathe in, but entirely capable of speech for minutes as they slowly die.

Second Demonstration:It is much easier to force air out than it is to draw air in. To demonstrate, take a normal breath (not deep) in and out. After you exhale, pinch your nose shut with one hand and hold your other hand very tightly over your mouth. When you breathe in you will either be unable to breathe in or you will only breathe in a sliver of air. But if you force the air out, you will note that it is able to come out past your hand, it will cause your hand and fingers to vibrate, and there is still a good chunk of air in your lungs despite you having exhaled. Now, imagine your fingers and hand are your Larynx (voice box). That's how speech is still possible in a situation where someone is being suffocated.

Final Thoughts

So why are you suffocating if so much air is still in your lungs? Part of the problem is that the air left over in the lungs after exhalation is not oxygenated, so your lungs are full of CO2 gas. This air is useless to your blood, so even though your bronchioles are full of air, you are still suffocating to death.

*Obesity: Not Everyone Has The Same Lung Capacity: There are factors that can make a person have a smaller lung capacity than someone else. These factors include:

Being obese

Being a female

Living at low altitudes

Being a smoker
While the third and fourth are probably not terribly important for our purposes, the first two certainly are. This is important because not only does an obese person have smaller lung capacity, they also can have their lungs fail to expand due to their own body weight if they are lying on the ground facedown. An obese person is at extreme risk of suffocation in any instance where their airways are being blocked or where they are cuffed and on the ground. Don't fuck around if they say they can't breathe, they're probably not lying.*

Personal Experience - I have personally been in this situation before. After I had the person handcuffed and on the ground for about 20 seconds, they began to wheeze. This is an immediate symptom of them not being able to breathe. I asked if he was having trouble breathing. I let him stand up, get some breaths, and then sit down. If I had simply knelt on his back during this time, I could have killed him. Instead, I eased off, stood him up to get him some air, and all was well."
-Taken from a reddit post on /r/protectandserve that you can find here:

This petition is directed towards police departments in order to have them teach all current and future officers that "If you can speak, you can breathe" is a misconception. While it is necessary to detain a suspect, officers must understand this can be done in a manner that upholds both their safety and that of the suspect. The major issue is not delibrate cruelty but ignorance of what actions can result in suffocation of the detainee.

Success means that police departments start programs that trains current and future officers in which actions can harm the person in custody by compressing their lungs. Such training can be easily iimplemented in regular training of police officers and would be within the interest of the departments to avoid future accidental deaths, which can hurt the community's trust in the police.

Failure to do so would guarantee that the death of Eric Garner and the lesser-known McKenzie Cochran, both who cried out "I can't breathe" in their last moments only to be ignored, would not be the last time such a tragedy would unfold.


Cops Gone Rogue