A New York Police Union is Offering $500 to Stop Recording and Help Make Arrest

Sergeants Benevolent Association
Sergeants Benevolent Association

On Wednesday, August 22, 2018, at 10:30 am, Ed Mullins, the President of the New York City Sergeants Benevolent Association (SBA), will host a press...

Nathan Dimoff

The NYPD union is asking citizens to stop recording arrests, help the officers make the arrest, and in return get paid.

Hoping to win back the respect and love of the people, an NYPD union president is offering a $500 cash reward to citizens to help them make arrests instead of record the arrests.

Sergeants Benevolent Association President Ed Mullins blamed the "Ferguson effect" for turning people against police, referring to the national backlash against cops after the 2014 shooting death of Michael Brown in Missouri.

He also blamed NYPD Commissioner James P. O'Neill for implementing a "hands off type policy of policing" that prevents them from arresting people who berate them on video.

And he also brought up instances of citizens standing around recording cops making arrests instead of helping them make the arrest.

The cash initiative is called 'Help a Cop' and Mullins insisted that the program is not to promote vigilantes or to promote citizens fighting crime.

According to NBC New York:

> "It's not a program of vigilantism, it's not against community imbalance and it's certainly not against people taking photos...people have the right to take photos of police photos," he said.

In the press release Mullins referred to an incident where an officer was fighting someone that they were trying to arrest in the 34 precinct where people stood around for 9 minutes recording without helping.

Currently, New York has a good Samaritan law, but does not shield civilians from liability if they choose to help an officer.

Mullins did state that there is a bill being drafted to change the current good Samaritan law so there can be protection to citizens.

Who qualifies for the cash reward is decided by a panel of experts, according to ABC7NY.

This initiative has got backlash from both citizens and the NYPD itself.

NYPD responded:

> "The NYPD encourages people to support their cops by calling 911. The department doesn't want to see people put in harm's way unnecessarily to collect a reward."

Photography Is Not A Crime reached out to News2Share co-founder and editor-in-chief, Ford Fischer, who records rallies, protests, and police interactions what his thoughts are on the new initiative.

Fischer responded:

> "The police creating a cash incentives for civilians to help them catch unwilling arrestees seems to taint the relationship between police and citizen. The incentive to physically participate in an arrest would disproportionately skew towards poor communities. The union noted that citizens often find themselves filming situations where police are using force instead of helping, as if thats a bad thing. Absent any monetary incentive, civilians know the value them filming police officers can have for truth, including the detainee if something is done wrong. Giving them cash to participate in the arrest rather than film it puts citizen on citizen and disincentives the sort of accountability video provides."

This press release comes on the verge of a "privileged and confidential" memo dated August 15 that was sent to every New York Police Department precinct which advises officers to arrest anyone that does not stop recording within the tax-funded buildings when asked.

According to the New York Post:

> Anyone videotaping inside these facilities will first be asked to stop recording, according to the memo, released on Wednesday and citing a recent update to the departments patrol guide. If a person wont stop recording, they will be asked to leave and those who still refuse can be arrested, the document states.

New York law enforcement has had a long ugly past with thinking photography is a crime and getting really upset when on camera and if it were not for a camera recording many interactions would go unnoticed.

Last week, two videos surfaced of NYPD using military type tactics to stop a family gathering.

Last month, an off duty NYPD officer was caught driving drunk on camera.

Earlier this year, NYPD was caught beating and tasering a man on camera.

In 2016, a security camera caught an NYPD officer in a physical lovers quarrel.

In 2015, the death of Eric Garner was recorded when a New York officer choked him to death.

In 2013, a NYPD officer detains a photographer and deletes the footage.

Also in 2013, a NYPD officer arrests a woman for recording a police interaction.

No matter how upset the Sergeants Benevolent Association, NYC Patrolmen's Benevolent Association, and NYPD get, remember photography is not a crime.

Comments (1)
No. 1-1

#FreeBao Bao Nguyen has been held in solitary confinement for way over a month in Tarrant County TX.

His crime? He did a livestream and someone watching the stream posted the home address of a Police Chief.

Some wanted a redress of greivences to the part-time judge/local attorney Darla Peavy.

Do you have a social media account?

Did you know you could be arrested and imprisoned for what a stranger may be commenting on your videos right now?

Please help get Mr. Nguyen freed from this unconstitutional imprisonment.


#FreeBao @Clash with Bao on YouTube

War on Photography